T.120/H.323 Harmonization problems
Recent conversations have exposed some problems with the T.120/H.323 harmonization changes that were made in Sunriver (mainly related to Gateway compatibility). Attached is a document that details the wording changes required to resolve these problems.
We realize that it is very late in the process, but these are real issues and we'd like to get them resolved if at all possible. Gary Thom has indicated to me that if there is general agreement to these changes, they can be included in the change document being submitted as a Delayed contribution.
The problems are as follows:
1. When communicating through a "smart" Gateway to an H.320 MCU, it is possible for the H.323 node to get a "waitForInvite" from the Gateway. However, the current text does not guarantee that the Gateway will have the transport address of the H.323 node. To fill this hole, the H.323 node MUST provide its transport address in the OLC if it is the slave (this will never happen if the node is the master).
2. When communicating through a "pass-through" Gateway to an H.320 node, it will sometimes be necessary for the Gateway to dictate how the call should be made. Therefore, the new text allows the responder to override the recommended setup procedure by ignoring the transport address in the OLC (and sending a transport address back in the OLC Ack).
3. The current t120SetupProcedure choices are not accurate. issueQueryAndJoin should really be just issueQuery (since it may be necessary to respond with something other than Join). issueCreate is not necessary, since conference creation is an implicit part of the OLC procedures. There is no need to differentiate between issueJoin and issueInvite, since master/slave determination indicates the required hierarchy. And finally, waitForInvite is only useful when the initiator is the slave. By using a more generic name, it could be useful regardless of who initiates the OLC (it can be interpreted as either wait for invite OR wait for join, depending on M/S). In summary, the suggested t120SetupProcedure choices are: originateCall; waitForCall; and issueQuery.
For more details on the exact suggested changes, please review the attached document.
Thank you for your consideration.
------------------------------------ Pat Galvin pgalvin@DataBeam.com Phone: +1-910-854-3551 Fax: +1-910-854-1983
begin 666 thrmchng.zip M4$L#!!0````(`'MQ)B0(!?0ZNA$```!(```9````2&%R;6]N:7IA=&EO;B!# M:&%N9V5S+F1O8^U;"W =U7G^]]ZKQ[5U+0D_\ M8V^#(1ESTL(WM`+$L^2&P M)=F2:V#,,*M[5[IKW[M[O;O7L@R>,24TGK3IT&EFF@<=(!/BIFEX-"U#*63< M3C-ABMNXGAK2.LD`P36)2<<&!H+'6/W^<W;OW?N096J@):,C?SIGS^L_YS__ MZZS61W_2^.IC3]]C4K2K12F"V-1J@[4*<"5_D,#T6RO[L+8V!A7S0+&)M-G M*OWL\11M?S4:X?/3`V>-XZ>U..!#UU-96CNSO*XL+20ZH!3R`XMD]<7R&<B? M\YXO)8<(TC][N5__ZZ5$K<C?P3-OZGVO_J/FNYJ(0L@S3?(YF&] _C?(Z["O MPTMD?@1TKT;]//#K#N0.\F4DUU,I'2BA1Q2C>E ,E:VD-)6V^Q1V+Y9Y*6?' MF^<_43^'"N-*<QZW+U0^3^GS+H\S?NK;UO7VRW-?4+Z*]FEX_M8B:2DFDH#2 M^7@=YY3">CZ9U);'M8=5T^JG2G-1%%U+75CO+VM?75L1;PM?E.T2W,U-8%& M4T^KL0=C`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`$_1'O?Y*!;?)(\84YI)W5X"Z65M=*3NE0EN_BC9>!AV)L\S MINL9MY)!WJ+*&=N1V"5X6IGM:&U6B]9V"4(D!5X8/>8:3.<-N:R_KKS5@UV0 MUF2(]^.I=HED82;+-H8-4YC<PFA>05/!LFEI6""'B4J;S/9'S)HTDD+J;-@@ MV.2*JQVRK4PQV25QM9<%;,1P].;*DN-Q`12U0;:%@H6#,%?B5+ `9[R!Q7(4 MX$-^QH1FVT;!5#AZ%EKNZOVNEMBE9GV-CPNK+?Q/LB##<A*/'UG;VL,J:("O MXXEML1;7_VPZ@K2T7E[T"ZX_FDXEE D3(7??5W;G(_J.C5;+Y6B4F_)8I7+ MQH6G]RRWV!VF$SR18\M:S-;I5N6RI:WWX$SL3SO5%R!.A*Z9J(J"=>>B4Z MGHI('15&`>;>L').VI^=5UJVB-BX>NM)W^5'0 GA`WF1?N@P3B14,! I:Z1$ MC4=$()0V=NGC1D&8W0M$"A,9K)RZ&&/!^=DLR^(XP)U"S)0W$)V2RW)9;$F\ M(*+R.HHH@4(VK25^Y&W+OCGZ1)DQ,ID-9,5TPNPR@_:*O&,,"3JB&:XZRW[ M\A;GVZ_@\H)CV74Y+BN?K_,5+%VSNC/GN*SC><=9(.(SV"GE,.]!1(LR9$,; M&U2AEB(Z#$1!6O!@QI?-O$_Y- +T`H]\L0RX$&&N,#8OD7JR3*!<A&$5W-+' M*"X%MU\B+A5)BQ#9L[25Q:*"SS%T,(E7)YS5$G%=L#B@+&S6*<PBYA9G[D=: MFKH3[@7T=N? *Q&W\GS]<&O;$; AZ-.BBC#OPKD_=((JF1>*,(1]$9Y0Q3 M9OLGUBW;`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`F K<#?0 M6$4T';@1N!?X"G ,. M$JHD6`=<!BX&EP$W ;N !X&G@+!"I(8H!=P&WU1+= M`Z2 _< O@551(@O(`H> [P%/`!"4Z<0S0(LX '@#X"'@2OKL%9@#J ";<!* MX#;@3B +7!7#FH#G@1#!Z81?1EX'O@WX!7@5!O@?IZ[!^X%S@-O <T-6)> M('X%Y@;V`J/ ^7/T[F^'SI'I\7/NR?IY"].HG!2/.*)JT[+GC]AK;Q?H[P ML4Q9>_\ZA=9O:UNPWB/B')'H;Y.UO>CO.U^OQ<_40C/=1U%K84G"FO12#60 MF$]]O/[[@*#WP#^"AB<090`DL"/@)> ("_`J&91#5 +: "JX&#P ^!EX"C MP E@ZRRB'4 *2 /'@9>!5X 3P$G@+2!V)=$T8!.P&3" T!;P!=F$ZV9+?. MN8/_A'2>/J!W?G/J-3IQ_,1/4#[UXO$7Z=0_TO/X>>X']-PI.O5].G6('I] MYC^1%,HI/I=W!DY-E.L*]3B+4.&T]$!/8]PSO2/0JS]0WAZ0B&"YOU12O/+O M<;EJV_V)V>+W?*A#J?X'];L5F#]5ZM3?0B?VE<C*]X$G@*> ?P=>!DX#_PU< M`.+3B98!'<!:X$Y@!S *_!WP"^ -X$V@&K)U*] %W#-#RJ +_#'P+> 9X (I MAQ?<KHALGG*>LS-T/C)V>,%O(][3N?*V?=/.4SC_]'JUR)Z)^EWDX>6?BH;+ M[!W.?G[1[-<3=_G4,NAF`]77A9YM?&I>J+GA3?YBHQHU-<JSC4HS_ZU<B<CO M-I0P+7W&T^W7@?> *'2W'I@'7 5<X^GYYX%;@ Y/'S^0Q"X]>Y^S,T79/,5_ MXB-YL>;]\95K,GTLB4^]2!9BTZB1:E%_.]6+'E?#Y)X="R&O[A%_U"48`9IY M,P<*<!D4)V6-0B'DT8VZ)E[)M,);889:9>89FG4S3:5M]]=(EB77?-YQHT4 M7M.($1L+(]H1)V"^&J5Q;GCZ?YV?^2)_.E3?2%5SP[VU.Z/&U!?JY'KKZ&X" MV5H8K%ULK")K6C'3TL),RV"Q*$*-KX6G7W,>VYH;5@Y%BO>\D#K6O#WV&/)9 M7?J0AON^RN-AFTMFT)$;+J!OBUTH5>AMY%'>A#FTI7@2E5XYEZJGT:1N>%# MD675_U C>E:+9<VB6\6(D'(K3>WH[XFWJKA>NW'H#S50XU'VEKROE9%'J[Y3 MS1HIZ=1Z/+I"//'W-&&A51'Q_52((@O&QG!6*I<Y[:_WO[IAEBIRDK",/M@S MQOA+B["TDCQ//:C/H9IMYB[3&C%Q/GV:JV[0TGL,4\E_OH.HB>9Y4[8`TT'K M1J 5N!?X"G ,. M$,/DBX#K@:> L$ :C8!=P&V0DGN %+ ?^"6P"J&>!62! M0"3P(? %'!P9HT,K>X#O@1#?@Z\ W@2> IX,? &>!]EDS(:A2H!QJ 3F + M/? 2\ 1X&? KX#S0 W"M-G () $,L >X$O 0\ W@6#3P+/`C"3@"O`^! M(3"V%HAZN JX!E"!U<#G@9N!@QZ^Z85.3P,_!'X.;)TNP2YO&@YFDP<#> LX MRRYMAC2SBX$O>.CPT#63!:*F"/,#B)3D?CE2TC;1^%)$*M26SE-YWO%;"L_G ME( P+NY:O2-I)7:DVMO:=VS4[(QE&OOD>UOOC: ;1_OOX(CK)QRA=NEI5_M, M;.:Z"4?P@+$U.W9LZ!A8M[WC3K5O^0VK6G:D-4>W=^JNNBQ-/7I+RVH:,?@- MII6FBW6]6!LG):*$'Z8LA1,**;ZU1%Y/S4H(.?^&*NJNJ]NDCY?H?Y548<'9 M3'+RO[*43S6@'49=%7*_3N:E7V7RMX?!)_D%'4S?Y_B'<Y_>Q\H+RI!!">QA M/6F4)D=^$3K+(_Z1TZ?-"^6 0O/AU1@U](CRB,(E3IRWTLQ9#X$!`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`??F.%GY/*\JKWSS&[VJ#9;Y&^>]:^<>G/.?/B[G>C5Y__R_ M3?#4$L!`A0`% ````@`>W$F) @%]#JZ$0```$@``!D````````````@`+:! M`````$AA<FUO;FEZ871I;VX@0VAA;F=E<RYD;V-02P4&``````$``0!'```` &\1$````` ` end
participants (1)
-
Pat Galvin