Bob,

 

I think this only highlights the issue: there are several different lists that are used and those lists are not used for the purpose for which they were established.  I see H.323 implementation questions on the H.323 Forum discussion list, for example.  And I see equipment troubleshooting issues on the Megaconference list.

 

Perhaps there’s no way to avoid that problem, though.  Even if I create a new list or a forum, people may have problems finding the resource in the first place.  Still, it would be good if there was a “right place” to direct such questions, perhaps it would be beneficial to a wider audience.  That’s my hope, anyway.

 

As of now, the poll seems to suggest that folks are pretty split on the issue.  Unfortunately, though, not enough people cast a vote to really be statistically valid.  It also suggest that interest is not high enough. (I had added the “Neither” to help me get a clear picture that folks are not interested. I would hope people use that if they think this is not needed.)

 

I also had a discussion on two other options:

·         Employ a web forum with RSS feeds so folks do not have to visit the web site more frequently than necessary

·         Employ a Wiki where people could manage the site content themselves

 

I’d be curious to see which of those people prefer.

 

Paul

 

From: Bob Dixon [mailto:dixon.8@osu.edu]
Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2009 4:12 PM
To: Paul E. Jones; h323-announce@lists.packetizer.com; itu-sg16@lists.packetizer.com; h323-implementers@lists.packetizer.com; packetizer-news@lists.packetizer.com; h323forum@mail.imtc.org
Subject: Re: [h323forum] Discussion Forum or Mailing List for Videoconferencing

 

Many of these kinds of questions are already discussed on the Megaconference mailing list.   The list originally was about the Megaconferences, but now is about all aspects of video conferencing, and it is widely used.  All are invited to join.

 

Bob

 

 

 

At 3:13 PM -0400 8/19/09, Paul E. Jones wrote:

 

 

image002 90.jpg

Folks,

 

First let me apologize for this very unusual message, but I would really very much appreciate your feedback and suggestions on this topic.

 

Over the past year, I have seen an increase in the number of videoconferencing-related questions.  Sometimes these questions are development-related (for which there are appropriate mailing lists), but more often lately I am getting a lot of end-user questions.

 

I get questions like "how do I configure product X to talk to product Y" or "how can I get video working with product X" or "what is the best video camera for use with my software videophone?"  I'm also now getting questions about using XMPP for audio and video communication, which is a fairly natural extension of the IM/presence standard.  (In case you were not aware, Google Talk is using XMPP and Google worked to define the Jingle extensions that make this possible.)

 

Unfortunately, I am unable to provide good answer to some of these questions, but I know others on these lists are.  Collectively, I think we could answer any question sent our direction.  And, keeping with the spirit of why Packetizer was created in the first place, I would really like to offer a place for people to go to get the needed answers to their problems.  Even you might have some questions and would like to have a place to go ask.

 

That said, you might feel differently.  So, before I create an on-line discussion forum or create a mailing list, I would like to get your input.  Should I create a discussion forum, mailing list, or neither?  Obviously, if I create it, I would want people to register / sign-up to participate, else it would be pointless.  If you feel like you would likely never bother with visiting this web site or subscribing to a mailing list, then I'd like to know that: say "neither".

 

Since there are over 1,000 people on these mailing lists (just considering those on Packetizer - likely more on the H.323 Forum list), I decided to create a poll for my benefit and the benefit of others who are interested in this topic.  So, please go cast your vote:

http://www.micropoll.com/akira/mpview/646129-195628

 

Please go take the poll, but do not do a "reply all" and send messages back to everybody.  If you do want to talk to me about this, though, feel free to reply to me privately.

 

Kindest Regards,

Paul E. Jones

Rapportuer, ITU-T Q2/16, Q12/16

 

 

---
You are currently subscribed to h323forum as: dixon.8@osu.edu
To unsubscribe send a blank email to leave-1786263-31884.2f2025ae2e57e71843298d80bed5cfde@mail.imtc.org

 

---
You are currently subscribed to h323forum as: dixon.8@osu.edu

To manage your work group subscriptions please visit
http://www.imtc.org/members_area/lists.asp


Spam
Not spam
Forget previous vote

 

 

--

Robert S. Dixon, Ph D, PE           
Chief Research Engineer
Ohio Academic and Research Network (OARnet)

Office Telephone: 614-292-1638
Fax:              614-247-7096