Hi All, Currently, my H264 plugin able to work with polycom. I found that the media statistic(polycom PVX ) only show the frame rate video format, and display the image if my sending encoded data is not more than 1.4KB.
In my code, I do the fragmentation once it greater than 1.4KB(like libx264 do).
However, I had read some documentations and all of them mentioned about H.241 only support the single NAL unit mode(mode 0).
I wonder how this mode handle if encoded data greater than 1.4KB(usually happen)???
Any Idea?
Thanks.
The single NAL mode of RFC3984 (or H.241 Annex A) is the default method in H.323 but is not the only method under the standard.
These are exchanged and negoitated via the MediaPacketizationCapability of the OLC or TCS
H264 Annex A "0.0.8.241.0.0.0.0"
RFC3984 NonInterleaved "0.0.8.241.0.0.0.1"
RFC3984 Interleaved "0.0.8.241.0.0.0.2"
from H.241 7.1 To avoid IP-layer packet fragmentation (which may increase header overhead and the probability of loss due to errors), H.264 NAL Units should be substantially shorter than the MTU size of the network. For example, on an Ethernet network with a 1472 byte MTU, a 1200 byte NAL Unit allows for addition of considerable header overhead without exceeding the MTU size of the network.
I hope that helps
Simon
_____
From: h323plus-bounces@lists.packetizer.com [mailto:h323plus-bounces@lists.packetizer.com] On Behalf Of ooi khai chin Sent: Monday, 23 November 2009 2:04 PM To: h323plus@lists.packetizer.com Subject: [h323plus] H264 PLUGIN in H323Plus
Hi All, Currently, my H264 plugin able to work with polycom. I found that the media statistic(polycom PVX ) only show the frame rate video format, and display the image if my sending encoded data is not more than 1.4KB.
In my code, I do the fragmentation once it greater than 1.4KB(like libx264 do).
However, I had read some documentations and all of them mentioned about H.241 only support the single NAL unit mode(mode 0).
I wonder how this mode handle if encoded data greater than 1.4KB(usually happen)???
Any Idea?
Thanks.
Hi Ooi,
Can you please tell me what all changes you have done in H.264 plugin to make it work?
At my end, I could load the H.264 plugin in OpenMCU. It decodes the video well but while encoding it is giving some trouble. I can see picture on mirial softphone but it freezes in few seconds. If I cover and uncover the camera on other leg, it agian shows picture for few seconds and then freezes again.
On mirial it shows me high cpu usage warning and packet loss warning. If I connect using Polycom PVX, I cant see anything. In media stats of polycom, it shows video frame rate as 0, high packet loss and Video Format as '----' on RX side.
I checked plugin code, there I found H264_PAYLOAD_SIZE is already set to 1400. I tried changing it to 1200 and 800. It didn't help.
Can you please tell me if you have done anything other than this?
Thanks, Prasad
On Mon, Nov 23, 2009 at 9:34 AM, ooi khai chin ooikhaichin@yahoo.comwrote:
Hi All, Currently, my H264 plugin able to work with polycom. I found that the media statistic(polycom PVX ) only show the frame rate video format, and display the image if my sending encoded data is not more than 1.4KB.
In my code, I do the fragmentation once it greater than 1.4KB(like libx264 do).
However, I had read some documentations and all of them mentioned about H.241 only support the single NAL unit mode(mode 0).
I wonder how this mode handle if encoded data greater than 1.4KB(usually happen)???
Any Idea?
Thanks.
Hi Prasad, Currently, I also facing the problem you face when I used Mirial softphone. This problem happen is because the fragmentation issue of libx264. You can see your picture is only your encoded data size less than 1.4KB by default. (that's is when you cover your camera, it's almost dark and will generate smaller encoded size). Then, it's looks like freeze, but actually is the problem of mirial software can't decode the picture properly when your encoded data size greater than 1.4KB.
So, why it behave like this since if it is fragmentation problem, then my decoder suppose can't decode it?
Currently, it is working fine if my both side using the my own H264 plugin, and my decoder can decode and display it. It happen only when talking to other softphone.
Any idea to solve it?
Thanks.
________________________________ From: Prasad Mohire prasadmohire@gmail.com To: ooi khai chin ooikhaichin@yahoo.com Cc: h323plus@lists.packetizer.com Sent: Mon, November 23, 2009 12:54:33 PM Subject: Re: [h323plus] H264 PLUGIN in H323Plus
Hi Ooi,
Can you please tell me what all changes you have done in H.264 plugin to make it work?
At my end, I could load the H.264 plugin in OpenMCU. It decodes the video well but while encoding it is giving some trouble. I can see picture on mirial softphone but it freezes in few seconds. If I cover and uncover the camera on other leg, it agian shows picture for few seconds and then freezes again.
On mirial it shows me high cpu usage warning and packet loss warning. If I connect using Polycom PVX, I cant see anything. In media stats of polycom, it shows video frame rate as 0, high packet loss and Video Format as '----' on RX side.
I checked plugin code, there I found H264_PAYLOAD_SIZE is already set to 1400. I tried changing it to 1200 and 800. It didn't help.
Can you please tell me if you have done anything other than this?
Thanks, Prasad
On Mon, Nov 23, 2009 at 9:34 AM, ooi khai chin ooikhaichin@yahoo.com wrote:
Hi All,
Currently, my H264 plugin able to work with polycom. I found that the media statistic(polycom PVX ) only show the frame rate video format, and display the image if my sending encoded data is not more than 1.4KB.
In my code, I do the fragmentation once it greater than 1.4KB(like libx264 do).
However, I had read some documentations and all of them mentioned about H.241 only support the single NAL unit mode(mode 0).
I wonder how this mode handle if encoded data greater than 1.4KB(usually happen)???
Any Idea?
Thanks.
participants (3)
-
ooi khai chin -
Prasad Mohire -
Simon Horne